Welcome to InsurSmart®

Ohio’s Choice for Affordable Home, Auto, and Commercial Insurance

Forget the call centers. Protect your home, car, and business with a partner who knows your name and your neighborhood.

Thousands of local families & businesses have trusted us

COMMUNITY FIRST

More Than Just Insurance.

We're Your Neighbors.

Terry and his team have been proudly serving area communities for decades, still family owned.

Bundle & Save

Over $900

This is the average annual savings for those who bundle with Insursmart.com agents.

Trusted & Experienced

Experience matters

Our primary carriers average over 150 years in business. Together we are trusted and experienced.

We’re Here 24/7/365

24/7/365

Local service when you need it. No one does it better than a local agent who knows you.

Learn more about our insurance products and coverages

At InsurSmart, we’ve built our business around understanding what you need and what’s important for you to protect. That’s why we offer a wide range of insurance products to meet your specific needs, including customized coverages.

Bundle with Progressive and save more, it’s that easy!

Protect your building, contents, and income with coverage tailored to your property type.

Coverage built for rentals, property damage, liability, and loss of rent protection.

Stay job-ready with protection for your tools, liability, and work vehicles.

Safeguard your lot, inventory, and operations from shop to showroom.

Keep your fleet moving with coverage for vehicles, drivers, and the road ahead.

Bundle key protections, liability, property, and more, Dto fit how you operate.

Affordable coverage for a set time period to help protect your family’s future.

REAL PEOPLE, REAL SUPPORT

Meet The Team

I’m a dedicated professional with diverse skills and have a lifelong passion for helping others. I graduated with honors from a trade school where I became an ASE certified auto technologist and then went on to certify in CPR. I am a licensed Property and Casualty agent in Ohio now building my own business. I enjoy the time helping clients get the information they need to make educated insurance decisions. On a personal note, I enjoy spending time with friends and family and watching NFL, NBA and UFC sporting events like many of my clients.

INSURANCE ASSOCIATE

Justin Green

With nearly 50 years of experience in the insurance industry, I offer a level of expertise and insight that few can match. As a dedicated local independent agent, I do more than sell policies. I help business and personal clients navigate risks, avoid common pitfalls, and build ironclad protection for their property, liability, and life insurance needs. Insurance is complex, but it shouldn't feel that way to you. By working side-by-side with me, we will craft a comprehensive, cost-effective strategy designed to perform when you need it most. Stop shopping alone. I’ll shop dozens of carriers to find you quality coverage at a price point you won’t likely find on your own. You and I know insurance is about more than numbers. It’s about peace of mind and you can’t ask for a better partner than a devoted veteran of the insurance business.

AGENCY OWNER AND PRINCIPAL

Terry McCarthy

Personal service, integrity and professionalism have been the cornerstone of my success in business the last 21 years in the Tri-State area. As a licensed property and casualty agent I will use the well-honed skills learned so far to help clients who need the right insurance information to help them save money and insure what is important to them. I enjoy being involved in my community through various groups while building my insurance agency. I am a proud family man, devoted father of two, and the grandfather of their children and seek clients with similar values.

INSURANCE ASSOCIATE

Chris Green

Get Your Personalized Quote

Tell us a little about what you need, and Terry or a team member will reach out shortly.

Your information is secure and never sold to third parties.

Comprehensive Auto Coverage

Protect your vehicle and yourself with our top-tier auto insurance plans.

Why choose our Auto coverage?

From daily commutes to cross-country road trips, our Auto Insurance plans are designed to keep you moving. We offer liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage tailored to your driving history and vehicle type. As a local agency, we understand the specific driving conditions of our city and ensure you are never underinsured.

Ready to save?

Get a custom quote for Comprehensive Auto Coverage in minutes.

Homeowners Insurance

Secure your sanctuary. Coverage for structural damage, personal property, and liability.

Why choose our Home coverage?

Your home is likely your biggest investment. Our Homeowners Insurance protects not just the roof over your head, but the life you have built inside it. We cover protection against natural disasters, theft, and accidents. Plus, ask us about bundling with Auto for significant savings.

Ready to save?

Get a custom quote for Comprehensive Auto Coverage in minutes.

Commercial & Business Liability

Safeguard your enterprise with policies built for modern business challenges.

Why choose our Business coverage?

Whether you run a main street shop or a consulting firm, our Business Insurance scales with you. We offer General Liability, Workers Compensation, and Commercial Property insurance. Let us handle the risk so you can focus on growth.

Ready to save?

Get a custom quote for Comprehensive Auto Coverage in minutes.

Life Insurance & Future Planning

Provide financial security for your loved ones with term, whole, and universal life options.

Why choose our Life coverage?

 Life insurance is about more than just a policy; it is about keeping promises to the ones you love. Whether you are looking for affordable Term Life to cover a mortgage or Whole Life for long-term legacy planning, we help you navigate the options. Ensure your family’s financial future is secure, no matter what happens.

Ready to save?

Get a custom quote for Comprehensive Auto Coverage in minutes.

Specialty & Recreational Insurance

Coverage for boats, RVs, motorcycles, and personal umbrella policies.

Why choose our Other Insurance coverage?

Life is meant to be enjoyed. Our “Other Insurance” category covers your toys and gaps in standard coverage. From boats, RVs, and motorcycles to Personal Umbrella policies that provide an extra layer of liability protection, we ensure every aspect of your lifestyle is guarded against the unexpected.

Ready to save?

Get a custom quote for Comprehensive Auto Coverage in minutes.